Opened 16 years ago

Closed 12 years ago

#374 closed defect (fixed)

ASUS M3A79-T Deluxe & AMD Phenom II X4 920 no USB & additional no APIC mode

Reported by: Karlheinz Schmidthaus Owned by:
Priority: major Milestone: Feedback pending
Component: ACPI PSD Version:
Keywords: Cc: Karlheinz Schmidthaus, ecslist@…

Description

The first problem is that the USB drivers are loaded but the USB mouse does not work. After the installation (only with PS/2-keyboard working) I found no solution to use the USB mouse or an USB memorystick. The switch /CD does not help.

Attachments (29)

acpi-log-M3A79-T.ziq (117.7 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
acpi.l01 (10.3 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
acpi.l02 (11.6 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
p_3294.jpg (73.2 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
rmview_irq_without_acpi.log (1.2 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
rmview_irq_with_acpi.log (1.5 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
acpi-log-M3A79-T_090209_PIC.ziq (122.2 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
with testbuild announced of 2009-02-09
acpi-log-M3A79-T_090210_SMP.ziq (122.6 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
Test with /SMP (USB not working, no LAN connection)
P_3297.jpg (53.7 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
last screen with ACPI.PSD /SMP /APIC and removing all USB-drivers from the config.sys
debug090211-001.log (2.1 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
with ACPI.PSD /SMP /APIC
kdb.ini (22 bytes ) - added by pasha 16 years ago.
ZOC090211-002.LOG (13.7 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
Debug-Log with /SMP /APIC /O1
acpi-v315pre_acpi.ziq (122.4 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
Test with ACPI315Pre without APIC
ZOC090302-001.LOG (13.0 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
Kernel Console log with ACPI315Pre
ZOC090302-002_NNOD_CD.LOG (12.5 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
dito, other options
ZOC090302-003.LOG (13.0 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
test 3
ZOC090302-004.LOG (17.2 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
test 4
ZOC090302-005.LOG (16.8 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
test 5
ZOC090302-006.LOG (13.8 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 16 years ago.
test 6
acpi-log-M3A79-T_090525_Test_NOD.ziq (125.2 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 15 years ago.
Test with /SMP /!NOD
ZOC090525-001.LOG (13.0 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 15 years ago.
Kernel Console Trace with /SMP /APIC
ZOC090525-002.LOG (10.6 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 15 years ago.
kernel Console trace without any parameter
ZOC090525-003.LOG (15.4 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 15 years ago.
Kernel Console Trace with /SMP /!NOD
ZOC090525-005.LOG (30.5 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 15 years ago.
another test with /!NOD
ZOC090525-006.LOG (19.7 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 15 years ago.
Kernel Console Trace with /SMP /R and link table
ZOC090525-007.LOG (14.5 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 15 years ago.
Kernel Console Trace with /SMP /APIC - fails
acpi-log-M3A79-T-ACPI_PIC_090603-001.ziq (125.2 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 15 years ago.
ACPI 3.16 only working in pic mode with /!NOD or link table
acpi-log-M3A79-T_090609_SMP_NOD.ziq (125.9 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 15 years ago.
acpi-log-M3A79-T-Deluxe_ACPI317_090909.ziq (124.8 KB ) - added by Karlheinz Schmidthaus 15 years ago.
/SMP /PIC /!NOD

Download all attachments as: .zip

Change History (61)

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Attachment: acpi-log-M3A79-T.ziq added

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Attachment: acpi.l01 added

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Attachment: acpi.l02 added

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Attachment: p_3294.jpg added

comment:1 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

The system is installed and running with panorama in PIC mode with the SMP kernel but there is no USB support. (eCS 2.0 RC6a)

Filesystem: Bootable JFS Memory: 4GB Graphic Card: HIS HD4350 Silence 512 MB Onboard Networking: loading, but not working

comment:2 by eco, 16 years ago

e-co:

USB problems..

What happens if you disable USB Legacy in BIOS Setup?

comment:3 by pasha, 16 years ago

Can you disable FireWire controller in BIOS? Do you sure, that you TV driver can use high IRQ?

comment:4 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Cc: Karlheinz Schmidthaus added

USB Legacy is disabled in BIOS Setup. I'm installed Panorama as video driver. Just 10 minutes ago i test without the ACPI.PSD and the system is running including USB Mouse.

comment:5 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Firewire is disable, nothing changed.

comment:6 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

additional note: without ACPI.PSD the network is running, I can ping the gateway. With ACPI.PSD in PIC mode it doesn't.

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Attachment: rmview_irq_without_acpi.log added

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Attachment: rmview_irq_with_acpi.log added

comment:7 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

The system boot with os2apic.psd in pic mode (networking is running and the usb-mouse is working), but it use 50W more power. How can I help to fix the problem with acpi.psd ?

comment:8 by pasha, 16 years ago

Please download experimental ACPI build from Mensys site:

  • Experimental build for you:

ACPI-APIC-BAT.ZIP

comment:9 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Nothing changed, no mouse (USB) and networking if ACPI.PSD is loaded.

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

with testbuild announced of 2009-02-09

comment:10 by pasha, 16 years ago

Why you don't use /SMP options? For add /APIC you need check driver for "Marvell Yukon 88E8056". Right driver is in ecomstation.ru

comment:11 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

USB and networking is only work without acpi.psd.

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Test with /SMP (USB not working, no LAN connection)

comment:12 by pasha, 16 years ago

Try use psd=acpi.psd /SMP /APIC and with /CD or without. You have many devices in IRQ10 and IRQ11. It can be problem for USB. APIC mode change IRQ and can help you

comment:13 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

with /SMP /APIC /CD the system does not boot. I see many lines with "PIC MASK IRQ0 mask:FFFFDCF9" on the screen in a loop.

comment:14 by pasha, 16 years ago

Photo of screen is better. Check for right options. Must be /SMP /APIC. /CD or not /CD need try. BTW, do you try with /SMP /APIC /CD and /SMP /APIC ?

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Attachment: P_3297.jpg added

last screen with ACPI.PSD /SMP /APIC and removing all USB-drivers from the config.sys

comment:15 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

yes, both done with the same result.

comment:16 by pasha, 16 years ago

ACPI-APIC.ZIP, need photo of screen

comment:17 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

can I help you with debugging over serial cable? If yes, how to do it? Serial port and cable to another PC is available and working with a terminal program.

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Attachment: debug090211-001.log added

with ACPI.PSD /SMP /APIC

comment:18 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

if you have a netop guest license I can give you access to the machine with the debugging console.

by pasha, 16 years ago

Attachment: kdb.ini added

comment:19 by pasha, 16 years ago

here you need add /O1 only. 1 mean com1, if use com2 - /O2. And place attached file to root of boot drive. I mean psd=acpi.psd /SMP /APIC /O1

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Attachment: ZOC090211-002.LOG added

Debug-Log with /SMP /APIC /O1

comment:20 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Note: same problem as other boards with AMD chipset?

But one thing is not the same: Some devices (USB & LAN) are only working if ACPI is not loaded.

comment:21 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Why does loading ACPI.PSD in PIC mode cause problems?

The OS2APIC.PSD is working, but cause high power consumption (additional 50W)

comment:22 by pasha, 16 years ago

Log from ACPI315PRE.ZIP pls

Please download experimental ACPI build from Mensys site:

  • Experimental build for you:

ACPI315PRE.ZIP

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Attachment: acpi-v315pre_acpi.ziq added

Test with ACPI315Pre without APIC

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Attachment: ZOC090302-001.LOG added

Kernel Console log with ACPI315Pre

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Attachment: ZOC090302-002_NNOD_CD.LOG added

dito, other options

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Attachment: ZOC090302-003.LOG added

test 3

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Attachment: ZOC090302-004.LOG added

test 4

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Attachment: ZOC090302-005.LOG added

test 5

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Attachment: ZOC090302-006.LOG added

test 6

comment:23 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Cc: ecslist@… added

comment:24 by pasha, 16 years ago

can you join to irc or ask to ICQ:32400130? For peer to peer debug. Else we will have debug very long time. If irc - say me about network/channel

comment:25 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 16 years ago

Version: 3.143.15

Since 2009-03-26 it is running with a special testbuild of acpi.psd 3.15 and the following mapping in the acpi.cfg:

LINK LNKA 7 LINK LNKB 10 LINK LNKC 10 LINK LNKD 11 LINK LNKE 10 LINK LNKG 10

But a big general SMP problem is not solved: the power consumption is 60W higher than running the W4 Kernel without ACPI.

Note: setgetstate does not work with AMD. I hope that this will be fixed.

comment:26 by pasha, 16 years ago

Owner: pasha removed

comment:27 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 15 years ago

with ACPI 3.15 (20090509, filesize Archiv 3182717 bytes) the system break after calling "acpiirq 1"

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 15 years ago

Test with /SMP /!NOD

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 15 years ago

Attachment: ZOC090525-001.LOG added

Kernel Console Trace with /SMP /APIC

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 15 years ago

Attachment: ZOC090525-002.LOG added

kernel Console trace without any parameter

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 15 years ago

Attachment: ZOC090525-003.LOG added

Kernel Console Trace with /SMP /!NOD

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 15 years ago

Attachment: ZOC090525-005.LOG added

another test with /!NOD

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 15 years ago

Attachment: ZOC090525-006.LOG added

Kernel Console Trace with /SMP /R and link table

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 15 years ago

Attachment: ZOC090525-007.LOG added

Kernel Console Trace with /SMP /APIC - fails

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 15 years ago

ACPI 3.16 only working in pic mode with /!NOD or link table

comment:28 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 15 years ago

note about power consumption: with W4-Kernel: 118 W Windows XP: 108 W with SMP-Kernel: 158 W

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 15 years ago

comment:29 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 15 years ago

Milestone: Release version 3.15Release version 3.16
Version: 3.15

After shutdown with poweroff running ACPI 3.16 with with /SMP /!NOD the system does not start after powerON. The result is a black screen, no bios menu or other. I need more that one reset od additional poweroff to force it working. Without ACPI and running the W4-Kernel it's always ok.

by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 15 years ago

/SMP /PIC /!NOD

comment:30 by Karlheinz Schmidthaus, 15 years ago

after running "acpiirq 1" the system lost devices like the HDD connection.

comment:31 by David Azarewicz, 13 years ago

Milestone: Release version 3.19Feedback pending

This ticket is really old and not really relevant to the current software. Have you tried the current version?

comment:32 by David Azarewicz, 12 years ago

Resolution: fixed
Status: newclosed

No response from reporter.

Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.