Opened 12 years ago

Closed 12 years ago

Last modified 12 years ago

#168 closed enhancement (invalid)

SmartCVS doesn't support OpenJDK

Reported by: Gabriele Gamba Owned by:
Priority: minor Milestone: Enhanced
Component: general Version:
Severity: medium Keywords: smartcvs
Cc:

Description

E:\programs\openjdk6\bin\JAVA.EXE -jar C:\PROGRAMS\smartcvs-7_1_6\LIB\smartcvs.jar
An incompatible Java version has been detected which has been reported to cause strange bugs. Aborting now.

This is in fact officially stated: http://www.syntevo.com/smartcvs/documentation.html?page=installation
"... beta version of OpenJDK [is] not sufficient"

On the other side, it works fine with Java 1.4.

Change History (10)

comment:1 by Martin Iturbide, 12 years ago

Hi Gabrielle

It is strange. With SmartSVN 7.0.3 I can run SmartSVN with
"java -Dsmartsvn.checkIncompatibleJava=false -jar smartsvn.jar"

I remember I used to run SmartCVS for testing, but I can no longer make it run. (version 7.1.6). Is it possible that the author forgot to add the "checkIncompatibleJava" on SmartCVS?

in reply to:  1 comment:2 by Gabriele Gamba, 12 years ago

Replying to martini:

Hi Gabrielle

It is strange. With SmartSVN 7.0.3 I can run SmartSVN with
"java -Dsmartsvn.checkIncompatibleJava=false -jar smartsvn.jar"

I remember I used to run SmartCVS for testing, but I can no longer make it run. (version 7.1.6). Is it possible that the author forgot to add the "checkIncompatibleJava" on SmartCVS?

Maybe OpenJDK people could ask for it? It seems strange to me that the bypass is available for SmartSVN and not for SmartCVS!

comment:3 by dmik, 12 years ago

Did you try the switch -Dsmartcvs.checkIncompatibleJava=false already? Note that "smartsvn" becomes "smartcvs".

comment:4 by Gabriele Gamba, 12 years ago

No luck:

C:\PROGRAMS\smartcvs-7_1_6\lib>E:\PROGRAMS\OPENJDK6\BIN\JAVA.EXE -Dsmartcvs.checkIncompatibleJava=false -jar smartcvs.jar

An incompatible Java version has been detected which has been reported to
cause strange bugs. Aborting now.

comment:5 by dmik, 12 years ago

Resolution: invalid
Status: newclosed

Then it should be reported to SmartCVS developers. We can't do anything about that.

comment:6 by Gabriele Gamba, 12 years ago

Just asked to Syntevo support to add smartcvs.checkIncompatibleJava=false to SmartCVS.

in reply to:  6 comment:7 by Gabriele Gamba, 12 years ago

Replying to ggamba:

Just asked to Syntevo support to add smartcvs.checkIncompatibleJava=false to SmartCVS.

SmartCVS generic bundle from

http://www.syntevo.com/smartcvs/download.html

doesn't check the Java version any more :-)

comment:8 by dmik, 12 years ago

Does it then work now?

comment:9 by Gabriele Gamba, 12 years ago

Yes :-) I did not use it too extensively, but it seems more stable than under 1.4.2.

comment:10 by dmik, 12 years ago

Great.

Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.